Brendan Rodgers rebuilt his reputation at Celtic but still has plenty to prove | Ewan Murray

At least Brendan Rodgers is constant. On exiting Celtic, thereby inflicting uproar amongst a component of the membership’s help, the 46-year-old managed to retain sentiment from his arrival in Glasgow in Might 2016. And with a straight face, at that.

“From the second I walked into Celtic Park I’ve been dwelling my dream and, along with the gamers, workers and supporters, we have now been on an incredible journey, which I’ll always remember,” Rodgers stated.

Whether or not any supervisor would choose to finish a “dream” 14 video games from a 3rd clear sweep of home trophies is open to debate. Partly, this factors to a theme apparent from final season onwards; glory in Scotland was not sufficient to carry the eye of Rodgers, not least when a return to the Premier League grew to become a viable possibility. Leicester’s curiosity within the former Liverpool supervisor had lasted for months.

In Scotland, there has already been an underplaying of how respectable a job Rodgers has walked – or run – into. It had been apparent he couldn’t swap Celtic for something greater up the Premier League ladder. Leicester had been an ideal match.

That Rodgers positioned such inventory in Celtic being “his” membership means the upset felt by the Scottish champions’ followers is comprehensible. It additionally undermines the hero worship afforded to Rodgers, plus the flawed sense that Celtic’s pursuit of 10 titles in succession has a wider resonance than even their very own government believes. The truth is that these in way more aggressive environments in Scotland shrug shoulders at recurring success by the most important membership there. Rodgers, whose greatest pre-Celtic achievement was play-off success with Swansea in 2011, completely revelled within the adulation and supply of seven trophies.

His expertise may have been enhanced by presiding over a membership the place the demand to win each sport far outstrips that of Leicester, simply as managing a crew who generally get pleasure from huge chunks of possession brings its personal distinct challenges. And consider it or not; it’s doable to be a poor supervisor of Celtic; see Tony Mowbray.

That Rodgers applied a relentless strategy to home soccer is past dispute. That he oversaw the event of expertise – Callum McGregor, James Forrest, Kieran Tierney and Ryan Christie the obvious examples – represents his key Celtic success. Early this season, with Celtic struggling, Rodgers referred to as a gathering throughout which he requested gamers to anonymously listing key ideas relating to each considered one of their teammates.

Every particular person was later issued with the element as relevant to them; Celtic’s kind was to enhance, in what offers a nod in the direction of Rodgers’ administration talent. Imagine it or not, it was not all the time all about him.

Fast information

Observe Guardian sport on social media

{Photograph}: Chesnot/Getty Pictures Europe
Thanks to your suggestions.

A deeper story had performed out by then. Rodgers’ disquiet with the Celtic board relating to what he considered because the failure to adequately again him in the summertime switch window disrupted relationships to a degree from which they may by no means totally get better. Dermot Desmond, Celtic’s key shareholder, locations such religion within the chief government, Peter Lawwell, that Rodgers had no scope to win the battle, by no means thoughts a struggle.

In reply to Rodgers’ unrest, his paymasters may readily level in the direction of a string of poor forays into the switch market as costing Celtic hundreds of thousands. Throughout Rodgers’ tenure, Celtic’s workers prices rocketed to shut to £60m per 12 months; 30 occasions a few of their home opponents. It might be no shock to see that spending curtailed now. Lee Congerton, employed and vehemently defended by Rodgers, has presided over an inauspicious recruitment run.

Rodgers puts a brave face on defeat at Valencia last week that brought a premature end to Celtic’s involvement in European competition.

Rodgers places a courageous face on defeat at Valencia final week that introduced a untimely finish to Celtic’s involvement in European competitors. {Photograph}: Jean Catuffe/Getty Pictures

A fiscal gulf – no fault of Celtic’s, in fact – didn’t halt wild celebration as Scottish success continued. Rodgers fairly loved being the large fish in a small pond, the place he wouldn’t assume twice of providing recommendation to different golf equipment or delivering powerpoint shows to out-of-work coaches. But there had been ample indication, even a 12 months in the past, that the Scottish scene – which Rodgers started to seek advice from as “up right here” – was not stimulating sufficient for a supervisor who regards himself as being within the prime tier.

The Fiver: join and get our every day soccer electronic mail.

In opposition to this backdrop, Rodgers’ failure to make correct inroads in European competitors was unusual. It additionally undermined what he may produce towards Hamilton or St Johnstone, the place annual wage payments equated to Rodgers’ personal wage. From 22 European ties “correct”, Rodgers mustered solely 5 wins. Whereas Neil Lennon and Gordon Strachan – twice – took Celtic to the final 16 of the Champions League, Rodgers discovered himself usually helpless towards severe opposition.

A delusion quickly developed in respect of this – fortunately enhanced by Rodgers – whereby his dreamy, free-flowing soccer got here at the price of efficient pragmatism. In fact, this Celtic crew regularly conceded dreadful objectives in Europe, a situation not intrinsically linked to programs or model of play in any respect. They didn’t assault with vigour. Defeat to AEK Athens on the qualifying part of this season’s Champions League represented a dire end result; the Greeks didn’t take a degree from subsequent group video games.

In nearly three years, Rodgers didn’t supply a formidable central defensive pairing for Celtic, as would require consideration this summer season. His beholding to Scott Brown was routinely uncovered outdoors Scotland’s goldfish bowl. A failure to correctly belief in Celtic’s academy gamers, the very best in Scotland by a distance, meant an over-reliance on costly mortgage offers.

Rodgers has factors to show again within the Premier League. That’s partly on account of the wounding circumstances by whichhe left Liverpool but in addition, whisper it, owing to shortcomings illustrated in Glasgow. Rodgers was superb for Celtic however it could be an error to disclaim the reverse can also be true. The membership haven’t any severe trigger to mourn his loss.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button