Qualcomm and Apple kick off latest patent case – CNET


Qualcomm, based mostly in San Diego, California, is likely one of the world’s largest cellular chipmakers. 

Shara Tibken/CNET

Apple and Qualcomm kicked off the most recent chapter in a long-running authorized battle over patents and licensing agreements within the chipmaker’s hometown of San Diego, California, on Monday.

Qualcomm, which provides chips and modems for a lot of the cell phone trade, says Apple infringed on three of its patents in some variations of the favored iPhone. 

The chipmaker needs as much as $1.41 per iPhone that infringed on its mental property offered throughout a sure interval between 2017 and 2018. The precise determine was not disclosed, although it is estimated to be within the tens of hundreds of thousands of . That sum can be a drop within the bucket for Apple — which briefly turned a $1 trillion firm final 12 months — however a victory for Qualcomm would assist to brandish its status as a cellular parts innovator. 

“Qualcomm, though it would not make a smartphone — it would not have a product that you simply and I might purchase — it develops loads of expertise in smartphones,” David Nelson, the lead legal professional representing Qualcomm, mentioned in a gap assertion on Monday. 

The trial issues three patents that Qualcomm claims Apple infringed on. One patent permits a smartphone to shortly connect with the web as soon as the system is turned on. One other offers with graphics processing and battery life. The third lets apps in your telephone obtain knowledge extra simply by directing site visitors between the apps processor and the modem.

Now enjoying: Watch this: Apple vs. Qualcomm: Court docket battles defined


Throughout opening remarks, each side zoomed in on the patent that focuses on boot-up expertise when the telephone is turned on. Nelson mentioned the expertise within the patent was “foundational” to the corporate’s work, lengthy earlier than it was registered. Apple claims Qualcomm stole the concept for that innovation from then-Apple engineer Arjuna Siva, who the corporate mentioned mentioned the concept with Qualcomm engineers in an e-mail.

“This one is really essentially the most outrageous allegation within the case,” Juanita Brooks, lead counsel for Apple, mentioned of the infringement declare in opening statements. “They took the concept from us and ran all the way down to the patent workplace.”

A protracted battle

The courtroom conflict between Apple and Qualcomm is a part of a wide-ranging authorized saga. Two years in the past, the Federal Commerce Fee, aided by heavyweights together with Apple and Intel, accused Qualcomm of working a monopoly in modem chips. The company argued Qualcomm’s excessive royalty charges stopped opponents from getting into the market, which has pushed up the price of telephones and damage shoppers. That trial passed off in January, and the events are at the moment ready for a call from US District Choose Lucy Koh.

The San Diego trial, presided over by US District Choose Dana Sabraw, is extra technical than the opposite fronts of the authorized battle. Nevertheless it may have implications on how your telephone is made and the way a lot it prices. The trial additionally units the stage for an April assembly between the 2 firms over licensing offers. The 2 firms have been arguing over royalties Apple paid Qualcomm for licensing the chipmaker’s expertise. Apple paid $7.50 per iPhone, however Apple COO Jeff Williams testified in January that the value ought to have been a fifth of that worth.

The iPhone was first launched in 2007, however the firm did not begin utilizing Qualcomm chips for community connectivity till 2011. In 2016, the corporate began utilizing Intel modems in some fashions of the iPhone 7 and seven Plus. Now, Apple has opted for Intel’s modems over Qualcomm’s in all its newest telephones. 

‘Eureka’ and ‘Maverick’

After opening statements on Monday, Qualcomm’s first witness was James Thompson, the corporate’s chief technologist. He described Qualcomm’s relationship with Apple. He mentioned the corporate sometimes started engaged on modems for an iPhone about 4 years earlier than the telephone can be launched. “We outlined the mobile part of that product,” he mentioned. 

He additionally mentioned each firms had nicknames for one another. Apple referred to as Qualcomm “Eureka,” and Qualcomm referred to as Apple “Maverick.”

A verdict within the San Diego trial, which will probably be determined by a jury of eight individuals, is predicted in mid-March.  

Initially revealed at 1:45 p.m. PT.
Replace, three:26 p.m. PT: Provides extra element from opening statements; and four:25 p.m. PT: Provides extra element.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button